Home/Guides/MEL Indicators

Reference guide

MEL indicators: how to design them so they can be measured

What is a MEL indicator?

A MEL indicator is an observable variable that shows whether a program result is occurring. Each indicator needs a definition, a calculation formula, a data source, a frequency and a person responsible. Without those five elements it is not an indicator: it is an intention written into a logical framework.

The indicator does not measure the result. It approximates it. "Percentage of graduates employed at six months" is not the same object as "labor market insertion": it is an observable signal that insertion is occurring. Confusing the indicator with the result leads to optimizing the figure instead of the change.

Why seven out of ten reach the report incomplete

The pattern repeats in almost every diagnostic we do. Indicators are defined when the proposal is written, when the priority is for the results framework to look solid to the funder. No one checks at that point whether the data exists, who will collect it and with what instrument.

The result shows up in the first reporting cycle: the indicator is committed, the source does not exist, and someone estimates the figure from whatever is available. That is the origin of the audit finding later summarized as the numbers not being reliable.

The practical rule. No indicator enters the matrix unless someone can say, right then, which instrument the data comes from and who collects it. If there is no answer, the indicator does not exist yet.

The technical sheet: the five fields that cannot be missing

FieldWhat it answersExample
Definition What exactly is counted and what is left out People who completed at least 80% of the program's sessions
Formula How it is calculated, with explicit numerator and denominator (People who completed / people enrolled) × 100
Source Which instrument or record the data comes from Attendance record by session, form F.03
Frequency How often it is measured At the close of each cohort
Owner Who collects the data and who validates the figure Field coordination collects, MEL specialist validates

When the program reports to a funder that uses standardized metrics, it is worth mapping each of your own indicators against a public catalog such as GIIN's IRIS+. The advantage is not theoretical: it shortens the discussion about whether the figure is comparable.

Output, outcome and impact indicators

LevelWhat it measuresExampleWho controls it
OutputWhat the program deliversNumber of people trainedThe program, directly
OutcomeThe change in those who participatePercentage employed at six monthsThe program influences, does not control
ImpactThe long-term change in the populationReduction in the youth unemployment rate in the areaThe program contributes, among other factors

Most matrices are loaded toward outputs, because they are the easy indicators to collect. A matrix that only has outputs measures activity, and with that you cannot answer whether the program worked.

At the other extreme, committing to impact indicators without an evaluation design that allows causality to be attributed produces a figure that cannot be defended. If you are going to measure impact, the design (experimental or quasi-experimental) has to be decided before the intervention starts, not at close.

How to verify that an indicator can be measured before committing to it

Four questions, in this order. If any has no answer, the indicator does not go in:

  1. Which instrument does the data come from? If the instrument does not exist yet, it has to be designed within the project, and with what budget.
  2. Who collects it and how long does it take? An indicator that requires a follow-up survey at six months has an operating cost that someone has to take on.
  3. Can it be collected in each reporting cycle? An annual indicator is no use for a quarterly report. It is better to declare the real frequency from the start instead of repeating last year's figure.
  4. What happens if the population does not respond? Every follow-up measurement loses cases. If the expected loss exceeds 30%, the indicator needs a replacement strategy or has to be changed.

Frequently asked questions

Next steps. Indicators are derived from the Theory of Change: if the causal framework is not clear, start with that guide. To see how indicators fit within the complete system, read what a MEL system is. The measurement kit includes the indicator matrix template with the technical sheets.

How many of your indicators have a defined source and owner?

If the answer is "not all of them", that is the bottleneck that will show up in the next reporting cycle.